Wartick, included in the answer, there are several external clues to suggest we should omit the passage. Those who speak with tongues should interpret that others may be edified, 1 corinthians 14. Anthony thiseltons commentary on 1 corinthians is the most thorough and complete commentary on this book available in english. Appendix to the regulative section regarding the gifts of the spirit 1 corinthians 14. Verses 15 the apostle, in the foregoing chapter, had himself preferred, and advised the corinthians to prefer, christian charity to all spiritual gifts. Dealing with the book of 1 corinthians, which was written to a carnal and baby church located in corinth, in greece. How the prophets or teachers should act in the church, 1 corinthians 14. And so esteem those things as most excellent which profit the greater part of men such as prophecy, that is to say, the gift of teaching and applying. Women should keep silence in the church, 1 corinthians 14. As in all the churches of the saints, women should remain silent in the churches. Let your women keep silence in the churches this is a restriction of, and an exception to one of the above rules, that all might prophesy. Christianity in a hostile culture volume 7 21st century biblical commentary series. Notice that the explanation in verse 34 indicates that headship is.
In applying bengels first principle and observing the transposition of verses 3435 in two different places, some scholars believe that 1 corinthians 14 was originally without verses 3435. But if we treat one scripture this way, what is to stop us treating every scripture this way. He begins with advising them of all spiritual gifts to prefer prophesying, and shows that this is much better than speaking with tongues, 1. The true gift of tongues occurred only three times that we know of 128 17. Besides the three synoptic gospels only 1 corinthians gives us detailed instructions concerning the lords supper. I and ii corinthians bob utley professor of hermeneutics biblical interpretation study guide commentary series new testament, vol. The problem tongues of 1 corinthians 14 involve the lyrics of songs 1 cor 14. The superiority of prophecy over tongues i corinthians 14. This compact commentary on 1 corinthians is both readable and full of insights that will engage students, ministers. It moves depending on which scribal branch a manuscript belongs to i. Mar 29, 2017 1 corinthians 14 34 meaning this is part of the series based on the thesis called putting a woman in her place by daniel koren. The same verb used about the disorders caused by speakers in tongues 1 corinthians 14.
Read commentary on this popular bible verse and understand the real meaning behind gods word using john gills. Finally, verses 57 and 58 give us a word about the victory that is ours in christ as. Most people in the world have no experience of lasting joy in their lives. The problem of tongues in i corinthians 14 alliance of. No, paul relied on the law to guide him in his decision. Anthony thiselton s lengthy new international greek testament commentary volume the first epistle to the corinthians 2000 has become a standard work on 1 corinthians. How the prophets or teachers should act in the church, 2933. However, to simplistically, arbitrarily lift verses 34 and 35 out of their context and contend that they contain a blanket requirement for women to remain completely silent in the assembly is to defeat and ignore pauls original application of 1 corinthians 14. The following are five of the most helpful commentaries on the first epistle to the corinthians. The doctrine of a crucified saviour, as advancing the glory of god, and humbling the creature before him. Exhortation to brotherly love, and reproof for divisions. Outline of 1 corinthians 14 prophecy preferred to the gift of tongues. Tongues, as the corinthians used them, were rather a token of judgment from god than mercy to any people. This whole section of this chapter 1 corinthians 14.
Tongues corinthian style are below the dignity of man and god 94, 18384 15. One could be misled by the word also, as if it were just an aside or a secondary confirmation. One of the answers to the question about what 1st corinthians 14. Enduring word bible commentary 1 corinthians chapter 14.
Verses 2125 in this passage the apostle pursues the argument, and reasons from other topics. In verse 32, paul reminds the greek corinthians of an example of the perverse, immoral morass that they left compared to the liberating and ennobling calling god has so graciously given them. Taylor pays careful attention to the nuances of the english translation niv, the greek text, and the units of meaning that are vital to interpreting this letter. Interpretations and applications of 1 corinthians 14. Pursue love, and desire spiritual gifts, but especially that you may prophesy. Study of first corinthians 14 bible baptist church. Before reading the commentary on chapter 14, make certain that you have read the commentary on chapters 12 and. New american commentary nac 9780805401288 by mark taylor.
I have linked to all the major works referenced, however not all of the articles and books are freely available online some must be purchased. A verse by verse study of the abuse of spiritual gifts. It would be going a great deal too far to say, that they who fulfilled the latter part of this command, were sure also to fulfil the former. At his table the members of his body express communion with him and with each other. There seems to be a contradiction between 1 corinthians 14. The holy spirit does not cause people to lose control over their own behaviour 1 corinthians 14. The plain manner in which the apostle preached christ crucified. Thats not to say its perfect, as fees understanding of the textual problem of 14. This is the paramount lesson taught in 1 corinthians 14.
They believe that verses 3435 were marginal gloss, which were subsequently incorporated into the text at two places. These instructions to timothy echo what paul earlier commanded the corinthians. When i wrote and presented this material i was teaching at magnolia bible college in kosciusko, mississippi. For god is not the author of confusion or disorder, or tumult, as the syriac renders it.
An examination of the whole context reveals that gods law was pauls sole authority. Over 20 years after its original appearance, i still think this is the best commentary on 1 corinthians. Biblical studiesnew testament commentaries1 corinthians. Thiselton the first epistle to the corinthians new international greek testament commentary, 2000. Easyenglish is a system of simple english designed by wycliffe associates uk. The person whom the holy spirit leads, acts in love. In verse 56 he shows that sin brought death, and sin is exposed by the words of the law of moses, a thought that he develops more fully in romans 7. You can find the best commentary on 1 corinthians for you using the tools on the right side. Several new testament passages are regarded as critical in the current debate about the roles of women in the church. They are not allowed to speak, but must be in submission, as the law says. What benefit may accrue from this in the public assemblies, 1 corinthians 14. Gordon fee, in his commentary on 1 corinthians new international commentary, also asserts that paul did not write 1 cor.
They are a sign of judgment, as the unknown tongues of the assyrians were in isaiahs day. The first epistle to the corinthians chapter fourteen objectives in studying this. Articles sermons topics books podcasts filter resources by ask pastor john. Tongues are false if no one can understand them as a foreign language 128 16. Gordon fee, in his commentary on i corinthians new international commentary also asserts that paul did not write vv. The academic lecture i have just uploaded as women in the assembly.
Payne are notable scholars who believe that 1 corinthians 14. Paul believed strongly that christians should allow the holy spirit to guide and to direct their lives galatians 5. These christians were immature, and unable to handle strong meat 1 cor 3. Perhaps we should read 1 corinthians 14 to exclude a different kind of speaking rather than the speaking that paul encourages in 1 corinthians 11.
A bible study in easyenglish 2800 word vocabulary on the book of 1 corinthians. Bible commentary 1 corinthians 14 christadephian books. This wellknown proverb is strategically placed in the resurrection chapter. He begins with advising them of all spiritual gifts to prefer prophesying, and shows that this is much better than speaking with tongues, 1 corinthians 14.
In this shorter commentary thiselton draws on his excellent exegesis from that volume but combines it afresh with keen practical and pastoral application for readers at all. Perhaps paul is saying that tongues are indeed a sign to unbelievers, but not a positive sign. Rather, to paraphrase, if i pray in another tongue, my understanding does no good for my listeners, unless they understand too. Christianity in a hostile culture volume 7 21st century biblical commentary series mitchell, dan, hindson, ed, couch, mal on. In this shorter commentary thiselton draws on his excellent exegesis from that volume but combines it afresh with keen practical and pastoral application for readers at all levels. The unprofitableness of speaking in unknown languages. His authorship was attested by clement of rome as early as a. Mark taylors commentary on 1 corinthians looks at pauls missionary journey to corinth where he planted a church and nurtured the new believers for approximately eighteen months. For anyone who speaks in a tongue does not speak to people but to god. Or, alternatively, paul does not mean that he himself cannot understand his meaning. Paul is acknowledged as the author both by the letter itself 1. Corinthian women, with their freer mood inclined towards emancipation comp. Nov 07, 2006 anthony thiselton s lengthy new international greek testament commentary volume the first epistle to the corinthians 2000 has become a standard work on 1 corinthians. He then verbally punches them in the nose by telling them the company that they keep is destroying them.
Other scholars who hold this position include straatman, fitzer, barrett, and ruef. It does not say they do it through their husbands, and in the context of 1 corinthians 11 14 the prophesying happens in the assembly. For some reason some of the women were creating disturbance in the public worship by their dress 1. All of our resources exist to guide you toward everlasting joy in jesus christ. Those who speak with tongues should interpret that others may be edified, 1822 what benefit may accrue from this in the public assemblies, 2328.
The nac is based on the niv translation and is primarily geared for students, ministers, and educated laity seeking to grasp scripture in a full and in a unified way without having to dig deeply into technical matters. Metzger, a textual commentary on the greek new testament, pp. In the law that is, the old testament it is written, with men of other tongues and other lips will i speak to this people. For one who speaks in a tongue speaks not to men but to god. Surely the new testament is written for the whole church. But fee is an outstanding guide as you work your way through 1 corinthians.
994 1080 1499 1275 791 508 297 1036 581 1128 1 1305 889 457 1418 1515 88 1335 1248 1294 247 137 353 446 1130 1489 184 389 85 697 112 1238 1353 1274 1369 1511 115 396 266 1447 1231 388 1492 191